14 years ago
Monday, November 2, 2009
Turkish Literature
I haven't read a book that was so difficult to set aside when my evil demon told me to get back into reality and the duties of everyday life, in a long time. Elif Shafak does beautiful work in telling an exciting story, providing cultural insight, making bold statements, and creating a need to learn more about two cultures that seem so distant, but in actuality aren't.
Elif Shafak is Turkish, was born in France, and has lived in numerous places over on the globe, partially due to her diplomatic family. Even though she is Turkish, still she includes the Armenian story in her novel. The stories taking place in her novel are not only exciting and a thrill to read, but also responsible. By making bold statements about the status of women, and confronting the Armenian genocide, she writes about subjects that many others would try to avoid or not know how to tactfully discuss within a novel.
While reading both The Bastard of Istanbul and Orhan Pamuk's The White Castle, I became more and more intrigued about the history and culture of Turkey, including the Kurdish and Armenian populations. The more I learn about Turkey, the more I want to know. By reading on one subject, many other subjects are involved that I need to know about in order to fully understand the first. It's very exciting! I hope that the high school students who might be reading Turkish literature will be this excited, too.
While Shafak describes the Turkish and Armenian conflict, in addition to the tradition vs. modernity dilemma that many people in Istanbul face, Pamuk discusses the eastern and westerner cultural clash. In Pamuk's The White Castle, two men, one Italian, the other Turkish, look astonishingly alike. That's because they are more alike than they like to admit. Only when they begin to acknowledge their similarities do they start to respect and understand one another. The Italian represents the West, or the Occident, while the Turk stands for the East/Orient.
Both novels deal with issues significant to the identity of Turkey, in specifically Istanbul. An identity that seems to be well defined - Turkey as a bridge between East and West - that is still worth discussing. Most literature and film that describes Turkey, inevitably describes an identity "dilemma."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Bastard of Istanbul is indeed wonderful! I love the way Shafak sets up particular scenes that allow for conversations filled with social commentary to unfold between characters. Great pick!
ReplyDeleteI also loved this book, and it opened my eyes to many different ideas that I haven't previously thought of. The stories were incredible and the author had a great way of bringing the reader into the story. I think this will spark great class discussions!
ReplyDeleteThe novels are very different from each other. I have to admit that I enjoyed _The Bastard of Istanbul_ more. I have lots of questions about the ending...
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed The Bastard of Istanbul! I thought were were many fascinating aspects to it; such as the 2 girls unique friendship considering all of their differences
ReplyDeleteI loved The Bastard of Istanbul, and I too had problems putting it down! I love the way Shafak deals with so many issues all at once, including identity crisis, feminism, and nationalism. I think Turkey, with its bridge-like status, is a great starting point from which to teach Middle Eastern literature.
ReplyDelete